|
Telling Tales of Billy Miner
by Lissa Millar
Senior Connector: Volume 14, Number 12, June 2006
Memories
last longer when they are shared. The simple act of
telling brings them back to life, makes them more vivid and
conveys them, like a gift, to others. Sometimes the
stories fade away, but the really good ones become part of a
family’s mythology, and a very few can contribute to the
mythology of society at large. Such is the case with the
legend of the gentleman bandit, Billy Miner.
For many
years, Peter Grauer has been collecting those stories, seeking
out anyone with first-and second-hand memories of the days
when Billy Miner and his cohorts roamed central and southern
B.C. He spent six years gleaning further information
from museum archives all over the southern half of the
province.
Then,
chock full of all those memories, stories and facts, he sat
down to produce a dense, detailed treatise on the legendary
train robber’s years in B.C.
"I had
the luxury of being able to sit in my office from November to
mid-March and do nothing but write ten to 12 hours a day,"
says Grauer. The resulting book, Interred with Their
Bones, Billy Miner in Canada 1903-1907 (Partners in
Publishing,2006, 600 pages), comes out at the end of May, one
hundred years after Miner and his friends robbed the Imperial
Limited train at Ducks Station, which is now known as Monte
Creek, and faced trial in Kamloops.
The
book, while centered on Miner, provides a snapshot of life in
the Interior at that time, including a detailed chapter on
Kamloops and its amenities. Numerous characters, long
forgotten, come to life again as their roles in the story,
however small, are revived.
The
factual accounts in Grauer’s book are enlivened by colourful
descriptions derived mainly from the memoirs of people who
encountered Miner, who went by the name of George Edwards.
"If it
wasn’t for people who are now long gone put- ting down their
reminiscences of long ago, I would have had a much harder time
writing this book," he says. Historian and author Peter
Grauer displays the book he wrote, documenting the stories
surrounding the bandit Billy Miner.
“There’s nobody left who were involved in the story. The last
person that I talked to was a man born in Barnhartvale in
1900. He met Billy Miner and his buddies when he was in
grade one at Campbell Creek School in Barnhartvale. He
told me, from first hand knowledge, stories of that time.”
Grauer credits that man, Toddy Pratt, who died in 1993, for
whetting his appetite for tales of Billy Miner.
“I read government documents, newspaper accounts and
telegrams, but the best things of all were the personal
anecdotes of people who had left them behind,” he says.
In most cases, people didn't expect their memories to be of
interest to anyone but their family, but in the historic
context, they are invaluable to researchers.
Grauer stresses that people should write down their memories
and submit them to the local archives.
“They don’t have to be Ernest Hemingway, they just have to
write it down. We all have our responsibility as keepers
of memories, because that is our window to the life of the
past and how the past affects us today. Most people
don’t take the time to think why certain things are done a
certain way and many times it ’s because of incidents that
happened a hundred years ago.”
Bill Miner’s status as a legend is partly due to his impact on
people and the stories he engendered, Grauer says.
As George Edwards, he cut a flamboyant figure. He spent
freely, flashed around $100 and $1,000 bills and boasted that
his pistols would protect him from theft.
“You don’t ride around Kamloops on a beautiful thoroughbred
racehorse sitting in a beautiful red leather saddle without
wanting to attract attention.”
He was particularly fond of women and children, and took the
time to get to know them. He told them stories, wrote
them letters and was very generous with his money.
“He could afford to. He stole all his money,” Grauer
says with a smile.
“He lived on in the minds of the women and children.
They passed on stories of a man they remembered as mannered
and gentle and who treated them with respect.”
In fact, Grauer says, Miner’s charming ways belied a devious
disregard for social conventions. People were shocked
when they learned that he was a liar and a thief.
“When you read the book you’ll see more of the classic
symptoms of a sociopath.”
Grauer says that he originally set out to dispel the myth of
Billy Miner.
“The accepted story is going to be set on its ear a bit, but
the myth is still going to be there.” One historic
detail that Grauer contests in the book is the identity of the
third man in Miner ’s band on the night of the robbery at
Ducks. The newspapers of the day, unrestrained by
current journalistic principles, condemned the wrong man and
influenced the trial, he says.
“A miscarriage of justice happened, which is detailed in the
book. An innocent man was jailed, and he died in jail.”
When further queried, he archly says we’ll just have to read
the book for more information.
One of the benefits of writing the book like this is the
people you encounter. Grauer was especially fortunate to
meet the daughters of Constable William Fernie, the provincial
policeman who captured Miner and his friends and brought them
to justice.
The Fernie sisters, Daphne and Mary, had never married and
were in their 90’s when Grauer and his wife Karen visited them
in Victoria. Daphne met them dressed in a smart sweater
and her best pearls.
“She was so excited about us being there, writing about her
father. There was never anything written about him.
What a treat it was that Peter’s book took us there,” Karen
says. In numerous letters written before she died,
Daphne Fernie passed her stories to Peter Grauer. Their
father spoke little of the Billy Miner affair, so she could
not relate his side of that story, but she was able to tell of
his career and his close relationship with First Nations
people.
“My correspondence with the Fernie sisters gave me the flavour
of what it was like to live in the Kamloops area at that
time,” he says.
On her last visit to Kamloops, Daphne donated her father ’s
fishing gear and some treasured family photographs to our
local museum.
The Grauers spent a good deal of time traveling around the
Kamloops region, seeking out sites of specific importance to
the story.
“How can you write with any ambience without visiting these
places? We traveled on roads that people don ’t know
exist that were main roads 100 years ago. When you drive
on those roads you can feel the weight of history on your
shoulders,” he says. Since writing the book, he sees
this area in a different light, always in association with
events of the past, which he believes people who read the book
will also experience.
“What it does is, it gives you an attachment to the land, and
attachment to the past and an attachment to the present.
The land stays the same - the people change.”
Tales like that of Billy Miner are important in that they
generate interest in history, which was one of his goals with
this book, he says.
“I wanted to achieve a pride and awareness in people in this
area for their own roots, their ancestors. When people
have that pride they are better stewards of the land and the
stories.”
Grauer would have to be considered a self-taught historian -
or perhaps a natural. His mother’s family, the Portmans,
homesteaded in the Kamloops area in 1885. He grew up in
Revelstoke in a family of avid readers and lovers of history.
He took three years of an arts program at UBC but, homesick
for Revelstoke and disenchanted with academic life, did not
graduate. Clearly, he did learn what was required to
produce a well-documented, credible and engagingly written
historic account.
A recognized expert on Billy Miner’s Canadian exploits, Grauer
has appeared in History Channel documentaries on the subject.
Formerly a manager with the City of Kamloops, he is currently
semi-retired and serving as project manager for the Aberdeen
Highlands housing subdivision. Now that this book is
finished, he says he may look into one of the many fascinating
people he encountered while doing his research “who deserve a
book on their own.”
“There are lots of stories, lots of characters that I would
love to be able to research.”
Grauer’s publicity touts his book as “the final word on Bill
Miner in Canada 1903- 1907 ”, but he admits that may be
premature. Since he began publicizing this self-
published book, he’s had some interesting calls from people
with new stories to tell, which, if substantiated, could add
new depth to the story. New developments, as well as
some interesting side stories, are posted on Grauer’s Web
site, www.billminer.ca.
Copies of the book will be available at At Second Glance
bookstore, 448 Victoria St. the end of May. Grauer will
have a book signing at the bookstore, on Sat., June 10 from
1-3 p.m. |